Is your shower leaking, inconveniently designed or out of date? Maybe you want to move it to a different part of your bathroom, or maybe you just hate the colors.
Whatever the issue, you may be unsure whether the solution you’re looking for is a remodel or a replacement.
Quick Answer – Remodel vs. Replacement
Are you looking to change the layout, make major structural fixes or move the shower or parts of the plumbing altogether? If that’s the case, then you need a shower remodel.
If your shower works fine but it’s outdated or has minor leaks or worn-out fixtures, you can get away with a shower replacement.
It’s important to get this answer right because a replacement is faster, simpler and more affordable than a remodel. A replacement essentially changes your current unit for a similar one.
A remodel is a substantial renovation that could involve moving plumbing and electricity around, moving the shower to a different part of the bathroom, digging into walls and flooring, and more.
In the article below, we’ll discuss both remodels and replacements, what kinds of problems lead to each one and how to decide which you need.
What’s the Average Lifespan of a Shower?
Showers typically last for around 10-15 years. The lifespan of your shower will be on the shorter end if it gets heavy use or if there’s mold or hard water damage. You also won’t get as much use from a shower that’s poorly installed in the first place, so it’s important to get it right.
Another consideration is how old your shower is. If your shower is relatively new and you need to fix light damage, such as small chips, it’s possible you could have it refinished.
Signs You Need to Replace Your Shower
If you’re experiencing any of the problems below, a replacement might be the answer instead of a full-on remodel.
Mold and Mildew That Won’t Go Away
Occasional mildew in the damp environment of a shower is one thing. However, if you find yourself regularly having to scrub away either or both, it may be time for a shower replacement.
Leaks, Puddles, or Water Damage
Minor leaks may only require a replacement. Taking care of these types of problems early with a shower replacement will prevent water damage from becoming more extensive.
Constant Clogs or Drain Issues
Old or damaged drains that are no longer functioning properly can be replaced without having to do a complete remodel.
Low or Fluctuating Water Pressure
This could be a valve problem or a problem with other parts of your plumbing system. A plumber can diagnose it and do a replacement if that’s the right solution.
Sudden Cold Spurts and Valve Failure
Your mixing valve may wear out over several years, but the whole valve body could also be at fault.
Outdated Design or Poor Accessibility
It may be time for a more contemporary look, or you may want to make the shower easier to get into and out of if you’re having mobility issues.
Rising Water Bills from Inefficient Fixtures
Newer, low-flow fixtures can reduce the amount of water wasted. With high-quality selections, you won’t notice a decrease in your actual flow and pressure.
Visible Wear and Tear (Rust, Cracks, Chipped Tile)
Over time, your shower will begin to show wear. That’s usually a sign that a replacement is due.
Safety Concerns (Slippery Floors, No Grab Bars)
These may be a concern alongside accessibility issues. It may be possible to install options to address safety concerns without a full remodel.
When a Shower Remodel Is the Better Option
There are a few situation in which a shower remodel is the better option. Some of the problems discussed above could require a remodel instead of a replacement depending on how serious they are or the extent of the work needed.
You may need a remodel for extensive accessibility changes, including adding seats, a walk-in design, multi-spray systems and alterations for ADA accessibility. If leaks or water damage have caused rot, a spongy floor or other structural issues, a remodel is best.
Changes in shower size or layout or moving plumbing or drain lines will also require a remodel. In some cases, this could be necessary if drain clogs indicate a more serious problem with your pipes.
Shower Replacement vs. Shower Remodel—Key Differences
Understanding the key differences between these two can also help you figure out which you are more likely to need.
Scope of Work
A remodel involves a major overhaul of your shower. A replacement is simply a surface-level upgrade.
Plumbing and Drain Changes
Moving the shower to another part of the room will involve a remodel. You can make a lot of changes with a replacement, but the shower remains in the same place.
Time and Installation
It may be possible to do a shower replacement in a single day. At most, it usually won’t take more than three days. A remodel can take anywhere from a few weeks to several months.
Cost Differences
The average cost nationwide for a shower remodel is $7,000, but it can range from $2,000-$9,000.
The cost of a shower replacement varies a great deal depending on what you’re having done, but it generally ranges from around $1,000-$8,000.
Return on Investment
A shower replacement offers an ROI of approximately 60% while a remodel offers a higher ROI at 65%-70% and broader impact.
| Replacement | Remodel | |
| Scope of Work | Surface-level upgrade | Major overhaul |
| Plumbing and Drain Changes | Stays in place | Relocation possible |
| Time and Installation | 1-3 days | Weeks to months |
| Cost Differences | $1,000 – $8,000 | Range: $2,000 – $9,000/ Avg: $7,000 |
| Return on Investment | 60% | 60%-70% |
Benefits of Replacing or Remodeling Your Shower
Whether you replace or remodel your shower, you will enjoy a number of different benefits. A new shower will be lower maintenance and more water efficient. You’ll enjoy better safety and accessibility, and you’ll appreciate a more updated design. Finally, either will boost your home’s resale value.
FAQs About Shower Replacement and Remodels
We’re happy to answer your questions about replacements and remodels. Below are some of the most common ones that we hear.
How often should a shower be replaced?
It’s generally a good idea to replace your shower every 10-15 years depending on such factors as how much usage it gets, the materials it’s made from and maintenance.
Can I just reglaze instead of replacing?
Reglazing may be a solution for small stains, chips or scratches. However, it is also a temporary solution, and for rust, leaks and more extensive damage, you’ll need a replacement.
What’s the cheapest way to upgrade an old shower?
A prefab fiberglass insert is one of the cheapest solutions. You could also upgrade with small changes, such as replacing outdated fixtures.
Do new showers save money on water bills?
Yes, more water efficient fixtures can help you save.
How do I know if a leak means a full remodel?
Spongy floors, recurring leaks, signs of a shower pan leak or other indications that damage to walls, floors or ceiling has occurred means you need a remodel.
Beautify Your Bathroom Today With a Shower Installation
If your shower is looking worn and out of date, you can probably update it with a replacement. A remodel involves a structural and functional overhaul while a replacement is fast and cost effective.
Is your shower getting old or using water inefficiently? It may be time for a replacement. Consider your shower’s age, efficiency and usability when deciding between a replacement and a remodel.
Our shower installation services can make you feel like you have a whole new bathroom! Contact us today about a shower installation for your home in the Orlando, FL area. You can count on us to be the punctual plumbers that you need.